The Hyper-Readers reading definitely brought
it all together for me. While these cartoons were online and not printed, I
definitely found myself skimming them more than actually reading them. In my
mind, they were more of an e-text and not a full text text. When things are
printed out, I read them easier and critique them more. If it’s on screen, my
mind just doesn’t really seem to care as much about them or take them as
seriously as the articles in print. It seems like I see the story, but I don’t really read the story. This is what I think reading visually is all about –
reading with your eyes and not with your brain. There’s definitely a specific niche
for this type of writing, as shown explicitly by McCloud. It’s a learned
process, and honestly, I’m not it’s biggest fan.
The A/V
projects have been an absolute joy for me to watch. They’ve each had their own
special unique flair that has really been interesting to see. Some have been
enjoyable like Carson’s elmo story or informative like Matt’s sidewalks. I
think it’s neat how we all had the same project, but they each came out
completely different. I really like the way that Savannah’s was filmed, but I
legitimately have no idea how to do that stuff. I also have a greater
appreciation of film majors after this project. They have to have such a
creative eye for detail that I never knew about. The biggest problem for me was
figuring out something to do that actually mattered. I’ve made picture
slideshow things before, but never video with text. There was a huge chunk of
nothing that was going on in my video that I was trying to split, but never got
it to work out. I couldn’t make it “seam-less” of sorts, and it just looked
silly, so I eventually gave up and decided to maybe try it in the future. As
for color, my whole video is black and white, text included. I dabbled around a
little bit with yellow and blue text coloring, but in the end, I settled for
all black and white because I wanted the sort of gloomy-ness. Which is why I
chose the music that I did. The music for me gave the whole poem more character
and I wanted to see if music could change the watcher’s perspective other than
just being based on the video and text alone.
I connect to your point of books being different than etext. Anybody can put text online, but that book in my hands seems to indicate more substantive ideas. While I have this logical argument in my head that valuable ideas can come from many sources, it doesn't always translate into practice.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I totally agree with this. Anyone can post anything on the internet and they know it. It seems like people don't put as much care into writing when it's just published online and not in print. A good example of that is this blog. I rarely edit it and never even read back through what I just typed before I post it. It's almost like word vomit. I just type what I'm thinking and never really go back to fix it. It just doesn't seem as legit and tangible as a book that I can physically hold. Publishers go to great lengths to find and correct errors in their publications. It almost seems like they take their writing more seriously than internet writers in many cases.
DeleteBooks ought to be seperate. I think there is time and place, like Dave said, sometimes I just want my mind to make the pictures.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely! People think I'm crazy a lot of times for saying this, but I truly think that words can show us things that images cannot. People always complain about movies never being as good as the book that they're based off of (think Hunger Games or Lord of the Rings). While media is awesome, there's just something about words. Words that spark emotion and building our own pictures in our minds are truly an amazing result of reading. Of course books and movies won't be the same. Word formation and visual sight actually use different sides of the brain. Which is why books and reading to me are so awesome!
DeleteI explored TLOR and what I enjoyed was experiencing 2 stories. Similar but different in subtle ways. The film was about the environment. The novels more with courage.
DeleteHey thanks for the compliment Molly. I thought you did a great job with your poem a/v project. So well good that I actually looked up the poem! So way to be a good rhetor. You are right in saying that our class did a great job!
ReplyDeleteThanks Savannah! I'm so glad you liked it and looked up the poem. It's seriously one of my favorites since I was a little kid :)
Delete